Hi John Guiver,
I understand how frustrating and concerning this situation can be, especially when you’re being asked for something you don’t recall setting up.
I can see that Q&A Assist has already shared some initial guidance, so I’ll summarize the main points here to help make things clearer. On many Surface devices, BitLocker can turn on automatically during the initial Windows setup, even if it wasn’t manually enabled. When Windows detects a change it considers a potential security risk, such as a firmware update, recovery attempt or system issue, it may require the BitLocker recovery key before allowing certain repair or reset options to continue.
The recovery key can only be stored in specific locations. Most commonly, it’s saved to the Microsoft account that was used when the device was first set up. Please check all Microsoft accounts you may have used on this device by visiting: https://aka.ms/myrecoverykey. If the device was ever signed in with a work or school account, even briefly, the key may be stored there instead.
If the recovery key can’t be found in any of the supported locations, there unfortunately isn’t a way to recreate or bypass it. Even Microsoft doesn’t have access to recovery keys, as this is by design to protect your data.
If the device becomes unbootable or further troubleshooting is required, the remaining option would be to reset or reinstall Windows using another working computer then download a Surface recovery image. Please note that this process would remove the existing data on the device.
I know this isn’t the outcome anyone hopes for, but I hope this helps clarify why you’re seeing the BitLocker prompt and what options are realistically available.
Please feel free to let me know how things are going or if you’d like help reviewing next steps.
If you have extra questions about this answer, please click "Comment".
Note: Please follow the steps in our documentation to enable e-mail notifications if you want to receive the related email notification for this thread.