Hello John,
I know it’s frustrating when the first few accounts work perfectly and the rest don’t create their profile folders on first sign‑in. The silver lining is that this almost always comes down to permissions or policy on the shared path, not a deeper Active Directory issue.
When a new user signs in, Windows tries to create their folder at the shared location. For that to succeed, both the share and NTFS permissions must allow new folders to be created automatically. If the first two users worked and the others don’t, it typically means the share is too restrictive, the NTFS root doesn’t grant “Creator Owner” or “Authenticated Users” the right to create subfolders, or the Group Policy for folder redirection/roaming profiles isn’t applying to the newer accounts.
Please check that “Everyone” or “Authenticated Users” have Create Folder/Append Data at the NTFS level, and that the share itself isn’t limited to those first accounts. A common best practice is to allow Full Control at the share and enforce access with NTFS. Next, run gpresult /h report.html on an affected user to confirm the profile path policy is applied, and if you’re using roaming profiles, verify the path on each user object in AD is correct and consistent.
I hope this helps,
If this guidance proves helpful, please kindly click “Accept Answer” so we know we’re heading in the right direction 😊. And of course, I’m here if you need further clarification or support.
Domic Vo.